# Will the Water Behave?

The Navier\-Stokes Millennium Prize problem told with a live fluid simulation in a glass flume

By Numa

Topic: Maths

[Open the interactive Jig](https://ask.jig.com/j/J6E0hEyjgrNm)

## Transcript

### 1. Will the water behave?

Water flows past a stone pillar in this glass tank, and coloured ink shows its path\. In 2000 a US$1,000,000 prize was offered for a question about the equations behind this water: do they always behave?

One of the seven Millennium Prize Problems, announced in Paris on 24 May 2000\. Drag in the water to stir it\.

### 2. Newton, for every drop

Imagine the water cut into tiny parcels\. For each one, force = mass × acceleration: pressure pushes it, friction with its neighbours slows it, and the flow carries it along\. Navier wrote this down in 1822 and Stokes in 1845\.

The arrows show the speed and direction of the water in each patch of the tank\.

### 3. Everywhere, every day

The same equations describe air, water, blood and the clouds of Jupiter\. Engineers solve them to forecast the weather, shape wings, racing cars and ships, size pipes and design heart valves\.

A wing lets the water slip smoothly past\. A flat plate across the stream leaves a wide, churning wake: that is drag\.

### 4. Calm or wild

Slow, syrupy flow slides around the pillar smoothly\. Faster, it starts to shed whirls, first left, then right: a von Kármán vortex street\. Faster still, the wake turns into turbulence\.

What matters is the Reynolds number: speed × size ÷ stickiness\. Pillar wakes start to swing at about 47; water in a pipe turns turbulent near 2,300\.

### 5. The same swirls, sky\-sized

Wind blowing past Guadalupe Island, off Mexico, leaves this very pattern in the clouds, whirls tens of kilometres across\. Wind past a wire sheds small whirls that make it sing, and they can make tall chimneys sway\.

Chimneys often wear a spiral fin, a helical strake, to break up the rhythm of the whirls\.

### 6. Big whirls, little whirls

Stir the tank and watch big whirls break into smaller ones, until friction turns the motion into warmth\. The same cascade runs from a rushing river to a stirred cup of coffee\.

Lewis Fry Richardson, 1922: "Big whirls have little whirls that feed on their velocity, and little whirls have lesser whirls and so on to viscosity — in the molecular sense\."

### 7. The million\-dollar question

Real water is three\-dimensional\. Start with a smooth flow in 3D: does it stay smooth forever, or can the speed at one point shoot to infinity in a finite time? That sudden breakdown is called a blow\-up\.

Stretch a whirl and it thins and spins faster, like a skater pulling in their arms\. Can that go on without limit?

### 8. Why it is so hard

In a flat, 2D world, whirls cannot be stretched, and mathematicians proved decades ago that the flow stays smooth\. In 3D, stretching could pack spin into ever smaller places, finer than any computer grid can follow\.

In 2022 Jiajie Chen and Thomas Hou gave a computer\-assisted proof of blow\-up for the frictionless Euler equations beside a wall, published in 2025\.

### 9. An answer, under review

In September 2026, a proof written by AI and checked by computer claimed that a carefully chosen smooth push from outside can make 3D flow blow up\. Experts are still checking it\. For water that nothing pushes, the question is still open: can our equations for weather and wings break down on their own?

In Sept 2026 the Clay Institute welcomed news that the problem had "apparently been settled", but its judging is "deliberately unhurried"\. No prize has been awarded\.
